How the Stock Rating Score Is Calculated and How to Read It
In short
The Rating tab gives a stock a score from 0 to 100 that bestshares.com calculates from public data, with up to 85 points for fundamentals (valuation, growth, quality and financial health) and 15 for market sentiment. It adds a sector rank, an economic moat assessment and a bull and bear case. It summarizes data and is not investment advice.
Open Apple's RatingOn this page
What is the stock rating?
The Rating is a single number from 0 to 100 that summarizes how a stock scores on a fixed set of measures. bestshares.com calculates it from public data: a company's reported financials, its share price, analyst estimates and price targets, news headlines, and disclosed trading by insiders, large investors and members of Congress.
It is a way to organize information, not a recommendation. The info icon next to Rating states this on the page: the score is provided for informational purposes only and is not investment advice. Two stocks with the same score can have very different risks, and the model cannot see things such as management quality, pending lawsuits or a new product.
How to use the Rating tab
- Open a stock and click the Rating tab, for example Apple's rating. The Rating tile on the overview links here through Full Analysis.
- Read the score ring and the Updated date. A badge such as +1.2 pts shows the change since the previous calculation.
- Check the summary rows: Fundamentals, Market Sentiment, Moat and Sector Rank.
- Open the breakdown. The Fundamentals card shows four bars, and the Sentiment card shows momentum, news tone and smart-money signals.
- Read the text sections: Moat, Bull Case, Bear Case and Executive Summary. Use the bear case as a checklist of risks to research.
- Compare with another stock in the same industry, since the score's thresholds are the same for every sector.
How to read the rating
Total score
| Part | Points | Labels |
|---|---|---|
| Fundamentals | 0 to 85 | Excellent (60+), Strong (45 to 59), Average (30 to 44), Weak (under 30) |
| Sentiment | 0 to 15 | Bullish (above 10), Neutral, Bearish (under 5) |
| Total | 0 to 100 | Ring is green at 70+, yellow at 40 to 69, red below 40 |
Fundamentals (85 points)
Each pillar shows its points, a label and a colored bar.
- Valuation (25): the price-to-earnings ratio (full points between 3 and 12, falling to almost none at 40), the PEG ratio (full points at 0.8 or less), whether the forward PE is lower than the trailing PE, and the gap between the price and both an estimated fair value and the analysts' median price target. Labels: Undervalued (15+), Fair (8 to 14), Overvalued (under 8). These are the model's labels, not a forecast of where the price will go.
- Growth (20): revenue growth and EPS growth, each a blend of the 3-year growth rate (40%), the latest quarter compared with a year earlier (35%) and the analysts' 3-year forecast (25%). A blended rate of about 18% a year earns full points. Labels: High (12+), Moderate, Stagnant (under 5).
- Quality (25): return on invested capital (full points at 20%), net profit margin (full points at 20%) and gross margin (full points at 50%). Labels: High (15+), Average, Low (under 8).
- Health (15): interest coverage, liquidity (current ratio) and debt measured against free cash flow, with full credit for a net cash position, plus the Piotroski F-Score. Labels: Fortress (11+), Stable, Weak (under 5).
Below the bars, Est. Fair Value shows the discounted cash flow value the valuation pillar uses, and the model it is based on: book value for banks, insurers and real estate, operating income for capital-heavy companies, and free cash flow after stock-based compensation (Adjusted FCF) for most others. You can test your own assumptions in the DCF Calculator.
Sentiment (15 points)
Sentiment starts at a neutral 7.5 and moves with:
- News tone of the eight latest headlines, shown as Constructive, Neutral or Cautious (up to ±3 points).
- RSI, a 0 to 100 momentum gauge: +1.5 when it is between 50 and 70 (a steady uptrend), -1.5 below 30.
- Institutional signals from options positioning and the change in institutional ownership (up to ±1.5).
- Super Inv., Insiders and Congress tiles: Accumulating or Reducing when at least two tracked super investors are adding or trimming; Bullish (Insider Buying) for open-market purchases by the CEO, CFO or president or several insider purchases; Bullish or Bearish when members of Congress mostly bought or sold. Routine insider selling counts as neutral.
Moat, bull case, bear case and executive summary
These text sections are written by an AI language model, using the scores and the company's financials, revenue segments and recent news. The Moat card gives a Wide, Narrow or None judgment with the moat types it sees, such as Brand Power or Switching Costs. The moat does not add points to the score. The Bull Case and Bear Case list the main arguments on each side, and the Executive Summary says what would need to go right and what to watch.
Sector rank
Sector Rank such as #12/80 places the total score among stocks in the same sector. Top 15% means the rank divided by the number of stocks in the sector. It compares scores only, so a high rank in a weak sector still says nothing about future returns.
Worked example: Apple's rating on November 11, 2026
Apple (AAPL) scored 57.3, down 0.4 points from 57.7 the day before (yellow ring).
| Pillar | Points | Label |
|---|---|---|
| Valuation | 3 / 25 | Overvalued |
| Growth | 12 / 20 | High |
| Quality | 25 / 25 | High |
| Health | 9 / 15 | Stable |
| Fundamentals | 49 / 85 | Strong |
| Sentiment | 8.3 / 15 | Neutral |
- Quality earned full marks: margins and returns on capital are very high.
- Valuation earned almost nothing: a PE near 39, a forward PEG above 5, a price far above the Est. Fair Value of $261.45 (Adjusted FCF model) and only about 1% below the analysts' price target of $352.50.
- Health lost points because Apple does not report interest expense separately, so interest coverage counted as zero, and its current ratio is only about 1.0. The maximum Piotroski score of 9 supplied most of the 9 points.
- Sentiment (8.3): RSI of 55.6 added points, while news tone was Cautious, super investors were Reducing and Congress was Bearish. Insider activity was Neutral (Routine Selling).
- Moat: Wide, citing Brand Power and Switching Costs.
- Sector Rank: #50 of 69 Technology stocks (Top 72%).
The score had been 62.3 on November 3 and 4, after Apple's fiscal fourth-quarter report, and fell to 57.4 on November 5 as the fundamentals points dropped from 55 to 49. The text sections were last rewritten on November 4 after the new quarterly financials. Read together: an exceptionally strong business that the model scores poorly on price.
Limitations and common mistakes
- Not a prediction. The score describes current data. It has not been shown to forecast returns, and a high score is not a reason to trade.
- One set of thresholds for all industries. Software, banks and utilities naturally have very different margins and multiples, so compare scores within an industry.
- Missing data scores zero. A metric the company does not report (like Apple's interest coverage) earns no points.
- Valuation dominates swings. Price moves change the PE and fair-value gap daily, so the score can fall while the business improves.
- Sentiment is noisy. Eight headlines and a momentum reading can flip quickly.
- Text can lag or err. The written sections are refreshed less often than the score and are machine-generated, so verify facts in the company's filings.
- Over-the-counter listings show the Super Investor and insider signals as not applicable when no such holdings or open-market trades are found, so these signals neither add to nor subtract from the score. Without analyst coverage, their fundamentals score is cut by 10% and capped at 65.
Where the data comes from
- Original sources: company 10-K and 10-Q filings and earnings releases, exchange prices, analyst estimates and price targets, news headlines, SEC Form 4 insider filings, 13F filings of large investors and congressional trading disclosures.
- How fresh it is: the score is recalculated every morning, Monday to Saturday. The written sections are refreshed when something material changes (new quarterly results, a move of 3 or more points, a change in the valuation label, new insider, super-investor or congressional activity, or a price-target change of about 7% or more), and otherwise about every three weeks. Routine rewrites are queued, so some can take longer than three weeks.
- Calculated by bestshares.com: the entire score, its labels, the estimated fair value and the sector rank. The moat, bull and bear cases and summary are generated by an AI language model from that data.
Frequently asked questions
Is the bestshares.com rating a recommendation to buy or sell?
No. It is a quantitative score built from public financial and market data, provided for information only. bestshares.com does not give buy or sell recommendations. A high score means the stock looks good on the model's fixed set of measures, which never capture everything that matters.
How is the stock rating calculated?
Up to 85 points come from fundamentals, split into valuation (25), growth (20), quality (25) and financial health (15). Up to 15 points come from market sentiment, which starts at a neutral 7.5 and moves with news tone, price momentum and the activity of institutions, insiders and members of Congress. The total is the sum of the two.
What is an economic moat?
A moat is a durable competitive advantage, such as a strong brand, high switching costs, network effects or a cost advantage, that protects a company's profits from competitors. The Rating tab labels it Wide, Narrow or None. The moat label is a written judgment and does not add points to the score.
Why did the score change when there was no news?
The score is recalculated every morning, and several inputs move with the share price, including the PE ratio, the gap to the estimated fair value and the RSI momentum reading. A rising price can lower the valuation score even when the business has not changed.
Why does a great company get only an average score?
Usually because of valuation. A business can earn full marks for quality and growth but few points for valuation when its shares trade at a high multiple of earnings, as Apple did in November 2026.
This guide is for educational purposes only and is not investment advice. See our data disclaimer.