# How to Read the Top Wall Street Research Firms Rankings

> Top Wall Street Research Firms ranks research firms by how the stocks they rated actually performed. Each firm gets a 0 to 5 star score built from its success rate, the average 12-month return after its ratings, how many ratings it published and how recently. Open a firm to see the stocks it covers and its latest price targets.

Source: https://bestshares.com/learning-center/top-analysts

Last reviewed: 2026-11-15

## What is the Top Wall Street Analysts ranking?

Banks and research firms employ **sell-side analysts** who publish a **rating** on a stock (such as Buy, Outperform, Hold or Underperform) and usually a **12-month price target**. These calls move prices and headlines, but they are rarely checked afterwards.

This page checks them. It scores each **research firm** on what actually happened to the stocks after its ratings, so you can see which firms' calls have held up and give more or less weight to a headline accordingly.

Each row is a **firm** (for example Morgan Stanley or D.A. Davidson), combining all ratings published under that firm's name, because ratings are published under the firm rather than the individual analyst.

## How to use the analyst rankings

1. Open [Top Wall Street Analysts](/analysts). The heading shows how many firms are ranked.
2. Read the default order, which is by *Rank*. Click a column header such as *Success Rate*, *Avg. Return* or *Total Ratings* to re-sort.
3. Use *Search analyst...* to find a firm by name.
4. Click a firm to open its profile, for example [Morgan Stanley](/analysts/94883418).
5. On the profile, read the four cards (*Rank*, *Total Ratings*, *Success Rate*, *Average Return*), then the *Covered Stocks* table.
6. Click the arrow at the start of a row to see that firm's rating history on the stock plotted against its price.

## How to read analyst rankings and profiles

### The star score

The stars and the number in brackets are a score from **0 to 5**, calculated by bestshares.com:

| Ingredient | Weight |
|---|---|
| Average return after ratings | 35% |
| Success rate | 35% |
| Number of ratings | 10% |
| How recent the last rating is | 10% |
| Return and volume versus other firms (percentiles) | 10% |

Adjustments then reward long, consistent records (for example many ratings with a success rate above 50%) and cap the score for weak or stale ones: firms below a 40% success rate cannot exceed 3.8, and firms silent for more than 90 days cannot exceed 4.2. A firm with **no rating in the last 365 days scores 0**, which is why many firms show zero stars.

### Ranking columns

- *Rank*: position by score, with ties broken by average return and then success rate.
- *Success Rate*: the percentage of **Buy-type** and **Sell-type** ratings where the stock moved in the rated direction over the following 12 months. A rating is scored once it is a year old. **Hold ratings are not scored.**
- *Avg. Return*: the average 12-month price change after each Buy-type or Sell-type rating, seen from the rating's side: a fall after a Sell-type rating counts as a gain. It ignores dividends.
- *Total Ratings*: every rating the firm has on record, including holds and repeated ratings that only update a price target.
- *Last Rating*: the date of the firm's most recent rating.

**Rating names are grouped.** Outperform, Overweight, Positive and similar labels count as Buy-type; Underperform, Underweight, Negative and Reduce count as Sell-type; Neutral, Equal-Weight, Market Perform and similar count as Hold.

### Firm profile

The header shows the firm's stars, then *Rank (of N)*, *Total Ratings*, *Success Rate* and *Average Return*. *Covered Stocks* lists each stock the firm rated in the last 12 months once, using its latest rating:

| Column | Meaning |
|---|---|
| *Action* | What the firm did and the rating, such as *Maintain: Buy* or *Downgrade: Equal Weight* |
| *Price Target* | The latest 12-month target; when the firm changed it, the previous target is shown before the arrow |
| *Current* | The latest share price |
| *% Upside* | Price Target ÷ Current − 1 |
| *Ratings* | How many ratings the firm has published on this stock |
| *Updated* | Date of the latest rating |

A positive *% Upside* means the target sits above today's price. A negative one usually means the stock has already passed the target.

## Worked example: Morgan Stanley's record

On November 15, 2026, Morgan Stanley's profile showed:

| Card | Value |
|---|---|
| Rank | 50 of 499 |
| Stars | 4.01 |
| Total Ratings | 37,611 |
| Success Rate | 64.54% |
| Average Return | +16.42% |

How to read it:

- **Large sample.** Over 37,000 ratings, and 1,006 stocks rated in the last 12 months, make the figures more reliable than those of a firm with a few hundred ratings.
- **Better than a coin flip.** About 65% of its Buy-type and Sell-type calls moved in the expected direction within a year.
- **Why it ranks 50th and not first.** Firms such as D.A. Davidson (rank 5, 77.56% success, +49.80% average return) score higher on the two heaviest ingredients.
- **One row in the table.** Apple shows *Maintain: Buy* with a *Price Target* of $355.00 → $350.00 on Nov 3, 2026, against a *Current* price of $356.27, so *% Upside* is −1.76%. The firm kept its Buy rating but trimmed its target, and the stock has since moved past it.

At the top of the list, BWS Financial showed a 100% success rate from far fewer ratings (382 in total). Always check *Total Ratings* before reading much into an extreme figure.

## Limitations and common mistakes

- **Firms, not people.** A firm's record mixes many analysts and sectors. A strong firm can still have a weak analyst on the stock you care about.
- **Direction only.** Success only asks whether the price was higher or lower after 12 months. A Buy-type call on a stock that rose 1% counts the same as one that doubled.
- **No benchmark.** Returns are not compared with the S&P 500, so in a strong market most Buy-type calls look successful.
- **Holds are ignored**, and most firms rarely publish Sell-type ratings, so success rates mostly measure Buy-type calls.
- **History starts in 2015.** Older ratings are not scored.

## Where the data comes from

- **Original source:** stock ratings and price targets published by brokerage and research firms, as announced in their rating changes and research notes.
- **How fresh it is:** new ratings are added and all scores, ranks and returns are recalculated once a night, Monday through Saturday.
- **Prices:** daily closing prices from US exchanges, used to measure what happened after each rating and to calculate *% Upside*.
- **Calculated by bestshares.com:** the star score, rank, success rate, average return, rating groupings and upside.

## Frequently asked questions

### How are Wall Street analysts ranked on bestshares.com?

Each research firm gets a score from 0 to 5 stars. Most of the weight goes to its success rate and to the average 12-month return of the stocks after its ratings, with smaller weights for the number of ratings and how recently it published. Firms with no rating in the past year score 0. The rank orders firms by score, then by average return and success rate.

### What is an analyst success rate?

It is the share of a firm's Buy-type and Sell-type ratings where the stock moved the way the rating implied over the next 12 months. A Buy-type rating counts as a success if the price was higher a year later; a Sell-type rating counts if it was lower. Hold ratings are not scored.

### Are the rankings for individual analysts or for firms?

For firms. Each row combines every rating a research firm such as Morgan Stanley or Wedbush has published, across all of its analysts. The page does not break results down by individual analyst.

### Do higher-ranked analysts give better advice?

A higher rank means the firm's past ratings were followed by better stock moves, on average, in the period measured. Past accuracy does not guarantee future accuracy, and a firm's record mixes many analysts, sectors and market conditions.

### How often are analyst rankings updated?

Rankings, success rates and returns are recalculated once a night, Monday through Saturday, after the day's new ratings are collected.

Open the tool: https://bestshares.com/analysts
